Friday, July 4, 2014

Lower Antelope Canyon - Ancient Deserts, Modern Art, Many People

Slot canyons are a but one manifestation of many different spectacular erosional features found throughout the Colorado Plateau, but they can be among the most magical of places. Here you'll find constricted channels where walls of polished rock form passages framing a narrow strip of sky, places where the sun is an infrequent visitor. The term "slot" refers to the vertical dimension of the canyon, defined as being significantly deeper than it is wide.

Lower Antelope Canyon from above

There are plenty of canyons in the slickrock wilderness of the Four Corners region, but perhaps the best known are Upper and Lower Antelope Canyon on the Navajo Reservation near the city of Page, Arizona. Not much to look at at from above perhaps, but hidden in the depths are twisting and fluted corridors of hazy golden light that attract thousands of visitors every year.

I usually avoid places as well known as Antelope Canyon particularly due to their popularity, but they are an essential feature of the southwestern landscape and should be included in the extensive catalog of spectacular earthly art. Just be warned if you go - this experience will be shared with many others, and photographers will need to exercise great patience to capture shots without human intrusion.

Lower Antelope Canyon

Page is a town created specifically by the Bureau of Reclamation during the construction of nearby Glen Canyon Dam.  Today the city functions as a hub for recreation on Lake Powell, the reservoir associated with the dam on the Colorado River.  Located just south of the Arizona - Utah border on the Navajo Nation, Page sits atop Manson Mesa in a high desert environment of sand and slickrock.

To reach Antelope Canyon visitors will travel east from Page about 2.5 miles on U.S. Highway 98.  Both Upper and Lower Antelope Canyon are administered by Navajo Nation Parks and Recreation Department.  All visitors must pay the required fees and be accompanied by guides, which are located on site.  For information on cost, hours of operation, and permits for specialty photography (beyond casual picture taking) see the Parks website here.

Also be aware that the Canyons may be closed at any time during the summer due to the threat of flash flooding.  In 1997 eleven sightseers were swept away and killed when a thunderstorm dropped heavy rain upstream.  To prevent similar tragedies tours are suspended whenever there is a likelihood of a storm in the area.

On arrival to the dirt parking area you'll see the large Navajo Power Generating Station looming over the landscape.  Naive tourists who inquire as to its purpose are often told that the area is so dry that it is a "cloud factory".  The joke is on us however, as the coal fired plant emits a haze which often obscures formerly crystal clear western skies.

Navajo Generating Station
There are two tour companies to choose from in the parking area.  Apparently one of them is operating illegally, although if that is the case I'm not sure how they are able to do so.  The company I went with (legally) is called Ken's Lower Antelope Canyon Tours.  The structure shown in the photo below will soon be replaced by a newer and more permanent facility.

Ken's Lower Antelope Canyon Tours (note new building in background)

Visitors are taken in groups of 20, with trips entering the canyon every few minutes.  Before departing for the entrance, the guide runs through a quick list of prohibited activities.  Once the introduction is complete the group heads across the sandy expanse of desert for the northern end of the slot.

The Rules

Heading out

Upon reaching the canyon, visitors plunge into the murky depths on a series of steep and sometimes slick (due to sand) staircases and ladders.  Waiting your turn to descend you get the sense that a lot of people are moved through the canyon every day.

Approaching the entrance

Going down backwards is easier due to slick stair treads

People stack up on the way down
Once at the bottom, eyes take a few moments to adjust to lower light levels.  The canyon is so narrow that the sun almost never penetrates directly into the chasm, and what illumination exists is reflected off golden sandstone.  It is this particular quality that provides a colorful and rich ambient texture to photos.















I am a casual photographer at best, but can certainly understand why a serious photophile would want to spend hours trying to capture the textures and light that every bend and twist in the canyon offers.  Because of time constraints the tour group moves through fairly quickly, and the next group is not far behind.  I found myself lagging as far back as I could to take pictures with no humans in the frame.

Of course there were others of a like mind who wanted to shoo everyone through so they could take the perfect image, and even a few small groups of what looked like professional photographers with a private guide giving tips and tricks for the best shot.  Altogether there was not a hint of a wilderness experience to be found, but then again I knew that's not what Antelope Canyon is all about.

Climbing back into the harsh light of day
I guess I would have to say seeing Antelope Canyon was worthwhile, if only for the chance to take some great pictures.  Unfortunately it is not a place to linger and contemplate the work of nature, although it is certainly worthy of such.  It is a visual spectacle, and like some National Parks there is no choice but to share it with throngs of others who have also come to appreciate the view. 

I went, I saw, I took pictures.  One thing is certain - my next slot canyon experience will be a much more personal experience.  And I might share it with you.  Maybe.

Wednesday, May 14, 2014

Grand Canyon - The Nankoweap Trail

Colorado River in Marble Canyon

"The most difficult named trail".  "Not suitable for anyone with a fear of heights".  "Lots of exposure".  "Waterless".  "Not recommended for solo hikers".

Nankoweap Trail has an impressive resume of dire warnings, and in general I advise first time visitors to consider them carefully.  Even so, having hiked all the named trails and routes in Grand Canyon at one time or another, in my opinion Nankoweap is really no worse than most.

As I see it the biggest challenge is not that there is exposure, it's there's so much of it, occurring in both the long traverse of the Supai layer before Tilted Mesa, and again on the relatively short and steep descent from the mesa to the drop through the Tapeats formation.  There's literally a five mile stretch where a slip and fall would likely result in serious bodily harm or death, and anyone who is obsessed with the probability will not have an enjoyable hike.  Otherwise it's the Grand Canyon, where every outing into the backcountry is a calculated risk.

Like most trails in the Canyon, Nankoweap arose from a path used by natives to reach the River.  The Powell Expedition of 1882-1883 is credited with improving the route so that the team's geologist, a fellow named Charles Doolittle Walcott could bring instruments and horses into the area to study the rocks.  His findings resulted in a series of well known scientific papers, and eventually Mr. Walcott went on to succeed J.W. Powell as head of the U.S. Geological Survey.

In later years the trail gained notoriety as part of the so called "Horsethief Trail"  which was allegedly used by rustlers in Utah to drive stolen livestock across the Canyon into northern Arizona.  Given the current state of the path it is hard to believe any animal would willingly make the trip, not to mention how riders on horseback would negotiate some sections, but things may well have been different in the last century.

The word Nankoweap has two different attributions.  In one story John Wesley Powell is said to have used the Paiute word for "place that echoes" to name the canyon, while another has a similar sounding Indian word which means "people who were killed".  In this version the word Ninkuipi was given to this place to honor Paiutes who died in an attack by raiding Apaches.  Either way there is no mistaking the influence native people left on the area.  More on that later.

Getting There

***Important Update, July 2026*** - There have been multiple large wildfires that have impacted the North Kaibab Plateau and Saddle Mountain Wilderness areas since I published this post.  I have not personally been to this area in the interim, but based on information provided on post-fire effects I am certain that anyone attempting to reach the Nankoweap trailhead from either approach will likely encounter significant erosion, increased flooding potential, and the possibility of falling/downed trees in severely burned areas.  Contact the Kaibab National Forest North Rim Ranger District office for more details.

There are two approaches to the Nankoweap trail.  The most reliable year-round access is from FR 8910 through House Rock Valley, which comes in at a lower elevation and usually has less snow in the winter.  The other way in is from FR 610 off the North Kaibab plateau.  The road here is affected by the seasonal closure of State Route 67 (usually mid-October through mid-May), as well as other factors such as fire and fallen trees.  If using FR 610 be sure to get current information from the North Kaibab Ranger District as restrictions may be in place.

These two roads access either end of Saddle Mountain Trail No. 57, which links House Rock Valley and the North Kaibab.  The junction with Nankoweap occurs at roughly the halfway point along the trail.  Entering from FR 610, the Saddle Mountain trail begins high on the rim at 8800 feet, and drops over the course of 3 miles to the Nankoweap trailhead at 7640 feet.  The positive here is that the beginning of the trip is all downhill, but hikers should consider that the extra 1200 feet will need to be tackled at the end.

Using the House Rock Valley access point, Trail 57 climbs 3.5 miles from 6800 feet to the beginning of Nankoweap, with an overall elevation gain of 1400 feet before reaching the rim of Grand Canyon.  The initial uphill climb may be challenging to some as packs are heaviest at the start of a trip, but consider the benefit of knowing the last leg of the hike out will be somewhat easier.  This post addresses a hike using the House Rock Valley entry and exit.

Other Considerations

Whichever end of the Saddle Mountain trail you use to reach the Nankoweap, the overall distance to the Colorado River is 14 miles.  There is no reliable source of water until Nankoweap Creek at around 12.5 miles.  While it possible to hike the entire distance in a day, the journey will be much more enjoyable if you allow for 2 days in each direction.  Since water is unavailable in the upper Canyon, plan to carry or cache sufficient supplies for dry camps coming and going.  Marion Point and Tilted Mesa make good destinations for overnight camping, with more choices for camping available at Tilted Mesa.

Helicopters fly a fixed route over Nankoweap during the day
Another item worth mentioning is that the entire route lies directly in the path of the designated air tour corridor, and from sunrise to sunset the noise of fixed wing aircraft and helicopters will likely be present.

While certainly a distraction at times, the flights are far enough overhead (Federal law requires helicopters to stay 800 feet above the rim, while fixed wing planes must remain even higher at 1200 feet) to mostly be a minimal nuisance.



House Rock Valley/Saddle Mountain Trail 57

From the parking area at the Saddle Mountain trailhead, the eponymous geographical feature rises above.  Starting with a deceptively gentle grade in a pinyon-juniper woodland, the path climbs in a generally southern direction along an old road.

Saddle Mountain Trail No. 57 from House Rock Valley
This continues for nearly a mile before making a turn to the east, where the first views into the chasm of Marble Canyon appear below.  Towering above the relatively flat House Rock Valley is the 1200 foot high escarpment of the Vermilion Cliffs to the north, and the smaller but no less dramatic Echo Cliffs on the northeast side. 

Vermilion Cliffs rise above House Rock Valley
Marble Canyon and Echo Cliffs
After climbing around 350 feet or so the trail makes an abrupt decent into a ravine, losing all the elevation gained to this point before beginning to ascend once more.


The trail continues upward through a mostly ponderosa pine forest, at first with a gentler grade in the dry creekbed.  There is still over 800 feet to climb though, and soon enough the path obliges with a sharper incline and few switchbacks.



Stopping frequently to rest and catch a breath in the shade of mature ponderosa trees, hikers may note evidence of the 1960 Saddle Mountain fire which burned around 8000 acres.  The vegetation here has made some progress in returning with Gambel Oak, manzanita, and small jack pines filling in the understory of the forest.

Eventually the trail begins to level off as it approaches the rim.  In a half mile or so you'll reach the intersection of Nankoweap with Trail 57 coming from the North Kaibab.


Saddle Mountain Trail No. 57 Junction
Nankoweap Trailhead - Elevation 7640'

After so much up, it's time to go down.  The first descent is relatively short but steep, a passage through Esplanade sandstone which leads directly to a lengthy traverse of the Supai layer below.

Dropping in through the Esplanade sandstone
Once you reach the Supai, the fun begins.  This long (5 miles) and somewhat torturous section is where people experience the most anxiety, as a path that is often no wider than a footprint winds over and through red rocks on the edge of the canyon, with drop offs into empty space mere feet away.




I am an experienced Canyon hiker with many miles under my boots, and exposure in general does not bother me.  There are always risks associated with hiking the wilderness of Grand Canyon, and falls from great heights are only one aspect.  That said this trail is really not for the faint of heart, particularly if vertigo an issue.

The traverse features not only narrow trails on the edge of certain injury or death, but also a lot of up and down.  Looking at a topographic map, the line representing the trail offers no clue as to the truly undulating nature of the Nankoweap, and it's for this reason among others that I recommend breaking up the trip into multiple days.

A welcome respite from the contour through the Supai comes at Marion Point, where a ridge extends into the Canyon and offers a small site for one or two tents.  Here it is easy to get confused as well - the trail does not continue along the ridge; instead it turns back to the north and continues the traverse.  Just past Marion Point at the head of a drainage is a small seasonal seep, which is only likely to have water after a very wet winter.

Marion Point
More exposure and more up and over continues until just before Tilted Mesa, where the trail finally makes a move towards the depths below.  Tilted Mesa is another ridge extending out into the Canyon, with just enough of a slope to accommodate a trail through the always challenging Redwall formation.  Here you'll find a few good camping spots along the ridge that make a suitable place to divide the trip.

The views from Tilted Mesa are pretty awesome as well, with the dry drainage of Little Nankoweap Creek to the east, and the upper watershed of Nankoweap to the southwest.

Little Nankoweap
Nankoweap Creek from Tilted Mesa
From Tilted Mesa on the path finally begins to get serious about losing elevation, beginning with a drop through the remainder of the Supai.  A couple of rock bands present a bit of a challenge, but old snags in proximity to the descent are helpful in making the downclimb.  Soon the trail reaches the top of the Redwall, following the ridge a bit longer before heading down.  The Redwall descent here is comparatively easy, especially relative to the sections immediately afterward.
 


There is a mercifully short but somewhat sketchy drop through a layer of yellow shale that has a very loose and steep surface, and hikers with heavy packs will be glad for a walking stick or trekking poles.


When that charming passage is finished, another delightful section begins where the path plunges steeply down a ridge of loose rock.  There is not a switchback to be seen in this part of the trail, and great care is needed to avoid a slip.

Yes, that's a trail
After the abrupt drop the trail resumes a slightly more reasonable descent, although still with areas of concern where hikers should exercise caution.  There is a 1/2 mile traverse of Bright Angel shale where the trail is narrow with significant exposure.  In many respects this area offers more challenge than the Supai, mostly because of a downward grade and loose material.


The trail is barely visible high on the slopes of Bright Angel shale
Once out of the Bright Angel, the Nankoweap begins a final descent through the Tapeats sandstone.



The hard part is finally over, as the trail winds down into a drainage.  The exit onto a broad terrace of depositional material above Nankoweap Creek signals the final approach.  Cottonwood trees in the streambed signal the presence of water and shade, and weary hikers can look forward to rest and relaxation in their midst.



Several good camping spots can be found on both sides of the trail confluence.  Water flows year-round in Nankoweap Creek, with springs located above and below the junction.

Hikers may also elect to continue to the Colorado River to camp on a beach.  Fair warning: those who do should know it is likely their spot will be overrun with river runners, since Nankoweap is very popular with river trips due to the granaries and large beach.  I prefer camping along the creek where you can rest assured of peace and quiet, and reaching the River is easy enough with a short day hike.



Once you've settled in, it's time to hike downstream to visit the River and the famous granaries located in the Redwall above the Colorado.  There is no established trail, but multiple paths meander in and out of the streambed, and crossing the creek occurs hundreds of time along the way.




There are small springs located at many places where water enters the creek out of fissures in the rock.  These provide habitat for moisture loving plants that only exist with direct access to water - look 10 feet on either side of the creekbed and all vegetation is of the desert adapted variety.



After a pleasant walk of about a mile and a half along the creek, the mouth of Nankoweap widens and the towering walls of Marble Canyon are revealed ahead.


At the Colorado a network of river runner created trails leads to the beaches where many trips stop to visit the granaries or spend the night.  Climbing up and out of the streambed to the south (right) will lead to the trail we're interested in - the one which ascends steeply to the sheer Redwall where ancestral puebloan granaries are found.


The granaries are easy to spot, and the trail which leads there is steep with big steps.  As you approach, there is another granary set into an alcove which has no apparent access.


These fascinating structures date back to a time around 800 - 900 years ago, when native peoples were farming creek and river deltas and storing corn and other food staples away from rodents and pests.  Given their age and popularity with river trips, the granaries are in remarkable condition.




Perched high on the slope above the River, the ancestral storage site offers a panoramic view downstream, with a great ledge to sit upon while reflecting on the people who built it.

The gorge here is narrow compared to the sections downstream, and the sheer walls of Marble Canyon rise over 3000 feet above the River.   Unlike the Canyon downstream, the space here is confined with only shallow benches to break the vertical relief.


Once you've had sufficient time to absorb the sights and sounds of Marble Canyon, it's time to return once more to isolated yet beautiful Nankoweap Creek.



Scorpionweed
Globe Mallow
After a restful day and a rewarding day hike to the River, it's great to simply sit in camp and allow the hours to slip away unnoticed while the sun continues it's arc overhead.  In this way it's possible to become part of the landscape, an object that belongs here as much as the rocks and trees which surround you.

You might even get lucky as a pair of mule deer walk within feet of your camp, untroubled by your presence and purpose.  That's a great way to spend the day.